Voting is closed.
This is the match up I was most intrigued with seeing as far as pairings go. I love how you tied it into something personal with Rajesh reminded of his own family relation, only to crack at the pivotal moment where he needed to prove himself. Its so common to go into these tournaments with artists keen to present their characters in a good light and have them be someone the reader can sympathize with while the opponent is more of a heel. To invert that and present us with an opponent whose the true hero and a protagonist whose a coward out to preserve their own life is so compelling because you just don't expect it. I found myself gasping when hit with that guilty run out of the cave in.
Your use of fill blacks and shadows is on full display in this comic in such a tasty way. It really adds oomph to the ominous situation Rajesh is negotiating not only for himself but with kindly old Eileen. I had no idea how you were going to axe everyone's favorite grandma, but I think your choice is so deliciously evil in such a different way- good on ya. Its also great to see you characterized Eileen not just as a burden but a tough old bird in her own right whose word and command of dialogue made her a formidable 'opponent'
a richly detailed vehicle interior as an establishing shot is SO GOOD. I also think your disaster and crowd scenes, which are NOT easy, seem to effortless here. Some clever tricks and use of spot blacks are utilized to great effect. The story and pages are just FUN and it shows panel to panel.
HOT DAMN CAMEL, what a stellar first round. This was so impressive!!!
that first page layout is delicious. Your use of spot blacks are also really effective.
What I really liked to was how effectively you used your panel layouts to emphasize the chaos of what's being depicted! Stable panels vs Jumpy shakey intermixed in the layouts was done really well.
and oh, Rajeesh remorsefully leaving Elieen in the rubble after saving him, oh that was so heartbreaking.
Just overall a really well done comic. Any Critiques I'd have would be nitpicks at this point. I can not wait for your round two. Awesome work man.
Hitting the ground as explosive as the ruptured tanks this is hands down one of the strongest entries this round, from expert use of minimal screentoning with Black-and-white this is an entry others what want to emulate the medium should study, and the promise of the premise of Rajesh's bio was delivered in spades! Excellent parallel movement with both the kaiju and the human sides of the story, weaving the scenario and the monster into everything happening, truly defining what "Kaiju Disaster" means. I had a feeling of the territory Rajesh's story would take and even though I wasn't too surprised by what I received in the climax it was still an emotional gut punch thanks to how well you crafted it. Simply fantastic start
Absolutely phenomenal showing for Rajesh. You used your opponent so well, and what a terrifying, saddening death for them. Trauma tying into the opponent going out was unexpected but incredible to see. I enjoyed the line weight, the deep black shadows and coloration and the use of negative space with white to represent lightning strikes or fire. It was fantastic, you crushed it here, Camel. I am glad you finished yours and the end result was so insanely well made!
Wonderfully done! I really loved your inks and paneling here, and your backgrounds are great! The page where Kudra was revealed was my favorite, it was so imposing and well done. Very much enjoyed Eileen’s and Rajesh’s interactions, she was so sweet to him, and her coming to his defense immediately made me smile. I would say my only regret is wanting more time with these characters. My heart broke to see Eileen crushed, but I can’t wait to see where this takes Rajesh in the next round.
SNOT DAMN! This comic is so damn good, actual peak. I can't believe you were able to get that much detail into the city it's actually amazing. I think everything in this comic is just working together so well, from the art style to the characterization of Rajesh, to how everything feels so heavy. I have no notes for this comic at all apart from keep this going in the later rounds and you will easily make it up to the finals and have an incredible shot at the win here. Peak comic. Probably my favourite of the round. Great work!
Man, I want to be you when I grow up. Your art is so fluid and organic, even where you left things messy, it fits perfectly. The shots you choose really emphasize the emotion you're going for. I'm also studying the way you and Eric both use half tones, you're great with them! You're also *so* good at drawing different people, not a single one of your background characters could be confused with one another, it's a masterful display of your cartooning skills. It also helps it feel like it's actually set in a city center, like, I've seen all of those people on the subway before. Your writing is also great, Rajesh is an interesting character, and that trauma response in the end? Ow, rude! Poor Granny. I'm not even sure what I would critique, especially with a two week draw time, honestly. All around, wonderfully done! Can't wait to see Rajesh in the next round ♥
Camel, it's always a treat whenever I see a comic from you and this one did not disappoint (not that I ever expected that to happen). You've truly mastered the use of spot blacks in comics and your storytelling is just amazing as always. Normally in battles like these, the victor/survivor is someone who's done something 'powerful' to save their lives. But in this case, I am (pleasantly) surprised that Rajesh survived by giving in to his fear. It is unexpected but honestly, a lot more believable. I love it! Can't wait to see what you offer for the next round!
This is everything I wanted out of a character like this, a matchup like this, and a scenario like this.
The art is phenomenal. Extremely bold and clear, great forms, really good character designs, really good EXTRAS too. My favorite is the guy who accuses Rajesh of unleashing Kudra on the public, his manic eyes just kind of floating in the middle of his askew glasses is a fantastic design choice. The backgrounds are very full and readable as well, really satisfying to scan for small details.
Eileen's representation I feel was done very well too, you kept her kind and humble and preserved the intention that she's in a state of health decades younger than she is, but I cannot stress this enough, when I look at those last few panels, I really do feel a strong pang of sadness. What must have been going through her head in that moment, that is heartwrenching and how dare you do that to me (positive). Rajesh shows he is the kind of good soul who will try his best to help, and Eileen proves she's the same when she defends him from crazed survivors, but all you needed was a single flash panel comparing Eileen with Rajesh's ailing father to communicate everything that needed communcating. Rajesh is scared, he's flawed, and he's in a situation that is going to test his priorities, and he's extremely human for that. I wish it could have ended any other way for Eileen, but I'd be a liar to claim I wouldn't do the same thing in Raj's shoes. (A part of me wants to argue that it would be even more fitting if fire, your scenario for this round, was the direct cause of Eileen's death, but I really don't want to think about how slow and agonizing that would have been, so you made the right call there.)
On top of all that the dialogue is great, I totally believe everyone that speaks could be a real person, and I love how grounded the whole thing is despite featuring a giant monster. Not that Kudra is the focus, but for an interaction like the one Rajesh and Eileen had, that is MORE than okay. No notes. Amazing work.
You've got this awesome style that it's a pleasure being in proximity to! I'm really taken in by the environments and the way you capture an accurate disaster scenario story in your writing. The use of black and white really make it stylish and help add to so much of the atmosphere, tension and mystery surrounding the kaiju attack! It really shows that you fully comitted to the tournament concepts and I'm rooting for you!
This was an impressive showing for two weeks the amount of detail in every panel is amazing! This entry has my favorite dialogue I was worried that it was going to be excessive but I found myself reading until the end with no noticeable lag. You use both Rajesh and Eileen so naturally it felt like they were both your characters. There's not much else to say this is just an all around solid entry. Great work!
Absolutely fantastic comic here. Love that you out here representing tones with me and doing it *so* well. Rajesh just looks like the physical embodiment of anxiety, cowardice, and desperation. The way they display those traits everywhere is really good characterization and your story is such a tremendous start that really feels appropriately kaiju disaster story with how the regular people are acting around in it. I am so excited to see how you're going to progress through this tournament and do more work as you do so. Fantastic work!
You are evil for this comic. EVIL!!!!!!!!!!! /j
jokes aside. WOW. The writing for this comic is stellar; I love the way it establishes the setting, Rajesh's character, and how his interactions with Eileen manage to tease his backstory in a very natural way. I would only suggest trimming down your opening dialogue a bit or spreading it out more, because larger texts slow down the reading experience by A LOT.
In terms of art, it's interesting. Very good use of spot blacks for dramatic effect, and you really know how to create some interesting page compositions. I guess my main issue is I wish you leaned into the spot blacks a little more because there are some pages that would look way better with more of them (page 7, 8, 9).I also think your art gets a bit too "loose" at times with hurts readability (page 8 panel 2, page 6 panel 3)
But that's it from me. I really, really like this comic. But also I hate you now. Never speak to me again /j

Mokuzuu
>> Camel
Did I ever tell you I’m weak to stories with old people and recognition? Well you know now.
I loved both the art and story for this one so much! A good balance of setting up the story with Kudra by using a lot of good environment shots, seeing the character’s interact through dialogue, and giving us a glimpse of Rajesh’s backstory so we know what to look forward to in future rounds! The ending was so sad, just the type of drama I’d expect from my Kaiju stories. . . But now I need to beat up Kudra for killing grandmas, EVIL BEING
Comment posted: November 15th, 2026 at 6:21 PM