Warren gets caught in the middle of the City's countermeasures to Kudra's arrival, a heavy offensive to try and deter it from going deeper into the city. Will Warren make it out alive? Or will the mysterious figure claiming to be a time traveler be his undoing?
Voting is closed.
Wonderful work! I love a man that’ll do anything for his furry best friend, and Macchiato is one lucky dog. I really liked your interpretation of the rewinding of time, it was really cool. My only nitpick is that some of the readability gets lost in your textures and the super dark shading. It was hard to make out just a couple of panels to where I had to zoom in and dissect what was going on. Beautifully done though!
Nicely done! I liked your story pretty good, but I will say that your lines and text bubbles need a little more care put into them, but that can come with building line confidence and using tools that your art program has like the ellipse tool or even the rectangle with the rounded corners. You did a good job of the backgrounds too, some of your best work on them that I’ve seen in a while. Keep up the good work though!
very nice comic Pizza man. I really like your story in this. I understand you destroying the time loop right away, that would be a lot to keep going in the story. I think you use Warren very smartly and the reveal to Rebecca that there are others who have been remembering was a very strong choice. With your art you gotta watch out for a few of your colours. Rebecca's skin tone and the floor are very similar as well as the time machine and her hair. You just want to add a bit more contrast there to keep them from blending together with your smaller lines. But I still think you did very well, always a fan at how you try new angles and push yourself to do wilder more adventurous panels or poses. Really nice start here!
Very tense and very atmospheric comic here. You really make those two work so well together, this is probably the most tense of the round. Starting your comic right in the middle of the action and Warrens escape attempt was very nice. I still think it would be cool to see a rougher brush from you for your lines but is what it is. I think the biggest thing in this comic that I would look out for in the future is just making sure that you keep your values readable. During the closer hand to hand sections with Warren and Rebecca the difference between your character values and the background is very minimal. With them being very dark as well it's not the easiest to see what's going on. You change the values a bit more make em stand out a bit more and it'll be golden. Rest of your art is very good, Hella dynamic, shit looks really nice, it's just a small nitpick about your values that gets me. But great job on this!
What a fun comic! I think you really made good use of all 13 of your pages and I think you told a really interesting story with a good smattering of humor in there.
I think you used the tourney premise really effectively and I think made overall good use of your opponent.
Some things I would keep in mind for future comics is while your overall page layouts are solid, I think being mindful of the composition of elements in them would be beneficial. Example, page 10 panel 2, when warren is doing an explanation, you could expand the bubbles featuring kudra a bit more to give more emphasis and visually balance out the panel more.
I also thinking being a bit more mindful with your text bubbles would be good, some of them get kinda cramped.
Solid work overall though dude! Nice job!
ooh what an interesting first round! I really like the conflict you set up between Warren and Rebecca. All for the love of a good dog.
I think you took a really neat approach and Im curious to see how Warren uses the time device in the future. I think it's a cool way to bring in story development between rounds, and a nod to the previous opponent.
You also have such a great use of dynamic shadow in your comics here, everything feels so delightfully intense and dramatic.
A minor note, something to maybe consider, is varying your line weight in comics a bit, I think it would compliment your shading style. A simple way to experiment with that is Background elements are in a thinner line weight, and foreground or focal elements in a thicker line.
Awesome work! I look forward to seeing more from you!
I have to admit I was pleasantly surprised by how robust this ended up being! A lot of thought put into this dialogue and the science of the time loop, and despite being essentially 13 pages of just back and forth talking I was never bored, that's a big deal in my book and you should be proud of that. The one hitch I had was the ending for two reasons: I was confused and needed a couple double takes to understand what had happened (did she shoot through Warren and it hit the time machine)? I also found myself a little bummed that the time machine was being broken and out of play *already*, without us getting a chance to even really see it in action. I get the stakes about breaking it and forcing Rebecca to have only one shot left to do this, but I think that would have been better delivered either after we got a chance to have some narrative fun and games with the concept (we came to her story for time travel shenanigans after all!) or wait until a future round to deliver that stakes-rise, given naturally and gradually. The scenario of airstrike is also a bit under-utilized for what could have been.
"Run" really is the most defining energy of this comic, its at a running pace from beginning to end, immediately in the action, then giving us a concise and quick understanding of the stakes, it was great to see that Warren though isn't just someone who runs away but someone who runs TOWARDs, a man of action, it was exciting to see him move perhaps on pure instinct after the building exploded, and even with the shocking twist of what happens the man wastes no time working to save Macchiato and we the reader are right there with him rooting him on and holding our breath as he does for each moment. You really did a great job of immersing us in the kaiju disaster with stakes that while simple are easy to understand and grab onto. On the visual front, I would recommend checking your brightness settings, there's a lot of moments that come off too dark, we lose a lot of what's happening, you may want to test showing your pages off to multiple folks and asking what they think about the darkness levels.
A solid entry! 13 pages in two weeks is no joke, and even with a few spots that look unfinished, it's a good showing! I liked the clever use of the groundhog day situation, and I think you did a good job incorporating Rebecca and Warren's backgrounds together. I loved the bit about Rebecca trying honesty, it almost working, and then Warren coming back immediately and ruining it, that was very funny. And what a bummer ending! Nice that you gave Warren a bit of a hero's ending, with him insisting she stop the time loop, even knowing he would die, it gives his death good meaning and impact. Artwise, I think you could learn more of the fundamentals (gross, I know); anatomy, perspective, all that jazz. You're obviously working on it though, and I especially love the confidence you show in your stylization in some of the panels, thinking of chibi Warren running back in and that panel on page 10 of him pointing up. I only mention those things to point you towards what you can work on though, this is great work!
Man I can't believe you killed Macchiato immediately, you monster! No but really, nice job on this, I'm glad she's safe haha. Your comic is cool and action-packed, I think you captured the energy of the panic well in those first few pages. I do wish there was a bit more involving your opponent, you used her competently, don't get me wrong, but we didn't get too much from her other than the time device. I think it would have been nice to at least see her in the background, squished by Kudra since Warren displaced her or something. But! Like I said to your opponent, 13 pages in two weeks is no joke, and the fact they're fully toned and everything is a lot of effort, great job! I think there's some art stuff you could work on, some of the tones and effects you have get a little muddy and confusing to look at in some spots, but not overly so. I'd also recommend drawing more dogs! Macchiato's anatomy is a lil all over the place. (That said, I think she looks so cute in page 10 panel 3, thats a quality floof). This is good work, though, and I can't wait to see more comics from you!
There may not have been any colour, but I could really feel the heat and impact of the air strikes in the shading alone. The constant presence of ash and grit and debris in the air in almost every single panel should be overwhelming, but its balanced so well it only ever adds to the chaos unfolding. The pacing and high contrast makes me feel like I'm in a movie theater and the facial expressions really sell the stress of the situation. Warren's really shown to be the type of person to forsake everything else to save what matters to him, and the relief of saving his dog pairs really nicely with the dread of Rebecca's words; yeah, you saved your dog, but what is that going to cost everyone else in the long run? Or is Rebecca vastly overestimating her own importance while dismissing Warren's? Guess we'll have to wait and see! Either way this was a feast for the eyeballs, and I had a great time. Fantastic job!
Not only do I really like the desperation present in this narrative, which is reinforced by the rougher style of the artwork, I'm a big fan of the emotional rollercoaster you forced me onto. I think I counted like... four or five spots where my expectations were abruptly pulled out from under me. I was thankful the loops are apparently mutable enough that things within them can change, then I laughed at Rebecca's attempt at honesty backfiring, then I was hopeful there was a way to use the machine the way Warren wanted to, then I was horrified at the implication that people aren't ALL THE WAY FORGETTING the loops and honestly it was a great ride, especially the finale wherein the machine Rebecca desperately wanted to protect is now probably doomed by her own hand. I also really respect the amount of intelligence you allowed your opponent to have, this Warren really seems like he might've been able to help if they could just align their outlooks, and also if he, y'know, wasn't destined to die. Maybe the threat of the air strike could've been around a little longer, but it was the whole reason they met, so I feel it served its purpose really. All in all, great job, I had a wonderful time!
OUGHHHH PIZZA MAN!
I really like the story you have going on here! I love how you established setting alongside the time bubble, and Rebecca is a fun character :) Very good use of your opponent, too. Warren leaves a strong impact on her that I hope comes back later.
I think my main issues are in regards to the art; This feels a little looser than your usual stuff, and some of your pages (most notably page 5, 8, 9) have a lot of medium shots or close-ups that make the compositions kinda boring to look at at times, plus the frequent lack of backgrounds makes this problem worse.
But god, I think the story makes up for it. Just be more careful with your compositions and it'll lift your comic's quality significantly.
Rora! Your art for this comic is very interesting; I love the high contrast approach you went with, with all these strong shadows and lights :) I think you should experiment more with it, as sometimes your dark objects kinda blend in with the background (like in page 2 where warren's silhouette is overlapped on top of a dark object in the bg) and sometimes all the strongs shadows make it hard to tell where the characters are situated. Additionally, while your cityscapes look wonderful from a distance, they look kinda desolate up close; you should try adding other things like cars, roads, lamp posts, big billboards, anything to give your setting a tinge more "personality".
Finally, in terms of composition: be careful with the 180 rule! Page 7 kinda breaks it in the fourth panel.
In terms of writing; I wish we had gotten more of an introduction to Warren as a character in this comic. Yeah, the intro comic gives us that, but your tournament comics should also be able to stand on their own without having to read supplementary material.
I also think the way you portrayed your opponent is kinda bare-bones. Rebecca just kinda comes in, kills Warren's dog, and is then killed off so Warren can get her time device. She feels more like a "means to an end" for the time device, rather than her own character.
If we had gotten a bit more of a *why* Rebecca was doing what she was doing, or a bit more of her quirks as a person, she would've felt more rounded overall.
Those page compositions are pretty nice tho (especially the rewind in page 9). I hope you stick around here in oculama, because this site is a great opportunity for you to get a lot of feedback at once from different people.
What I like the most from your comic is the expressiveness of your art style. I think you show you're not afraid to push the characters in ways to emphasise emotions and add some cartoony lightness which makes it a fun read across every page. I think you explored the unique quirks between the two of your characters in an interesting and compelling way which is always a tough challenge especially with how unique the two are!
This comic really stands out for your incredible art style and narrative pacing. I really feel the pressure of the city under attack by not only Kudra but by the military airstrike you got as your disaster scenario so I have to give you extra props for working well with the conditions! As mentioned in the previous review the two of your characters are very interesting and unique ideas and I equally compliment how you've synthesized a really compelling narrative using both of them to their full potential.
The time dilemma is such a rich theme to mine from and its evident in this comic where we see Rebecca and Warren debating the functionality of time loops and how it can be wrangled to wrangle the beast. Your visuals alongside the explanations of temporal shenanigans was so fun and a more dynamic move than just tying it all out as a back and forth talking heads panel. Showcasing your opponent by Giving Warren the dub to think of the idea to contain Kudra because it came to him in a dream that didnt go the way it usually does I think is a great subversion of expectations. I've said it in critiques before, but most characters in tournies follow a trope where the artist wants to make their character the protagonist who does no wrong, but having Rebecca kind of be the guilt ridden bad guy who was the architect of the city's demise is REALLY fun. Warrn went out a clever man who truly did end it. Good on em
While I do know its hard ,especially on a deadline, I will always champion for more environment work. You have an opponent who has such a great concept you've really run with, with the research crew and methods to her madness. I would've loved to have seen more details land personality put into the lab and and nuts and bolts of the time machine
Boy howdy I am winded after reading this one! I have never seen someone put so many steps in under such harrowing circumstances. From the title page we know what we're in for and I am here for it. I love that pose with Kudra's ominous foot cast Warren and poor Macchiato in utter shadow. That said you had me sweating bullets over "BUT DOES THE DOG DIE??" We all would let Kudra devastate a city for the chance at saving this pupper, I see nothing wrong with this. I also love this being such an innocuous temporal butterfly effect. You keep us on the edge of our seats and pay off the great cover art visual when these two gets stomped and narrowly miss being street pancakes.I don't care what anyone says- Dog savior Warren is the man.
There are some techniques and methods I would've loved to have seen tweaked to enhance your story and visuals you were getting across. The cellphone is a great example. Short of your pages being submitted in a bigger format or zooming in closer, the text combined with the rendering made for a tough read. There are great examples of comics displaying text messages with word bubbles that I think would've sung here trailing after Warren as he runs us through some lovely establishing shots of a terrorized city. I also think your inkwork is strong enough some solid spot blacks would've really made them impactful. As it stands your method of grayscale brushes where everything looked stippled, busy, noisy and on top of the snow hid alot of your great inks from standing on their own.
Some of your effects like the 'camera' swing from a head on view to a worms eye view to show off the jets was really wicked and some of my favorite panels.
I think out of all of the entries, your own design take on Kudra had to have been my favorite. hey just look like a bonafied BEAST. I especially enjoy the almost sharkish snout you gave em. This was a comic that just oozed urgency and stakes. Really great showing for round 1!
It's kind of funny but this is one of your death match characters I wish you had submitted as a regular one! I really like Becky and feel like her design and everything else going on with her makes her super interesting. That full body shot on page 5 is so cool looking and something that we don't see very often from you - but you really did a nice job with it! I hope we see more of it from you in future comics. The story and everything else is a very unique take. I remember you saying it was selfish of your storytelling in some aspect, but I don't think there's anything wrong with that when it's the story you want to tell. All in all, good comic.
You know, I was kind of expecting Warren to be a lot more in control of the situation before I read this comic. He definitely was a lot more panicked over their dog than I thought he would be. The art is looking really good, I love how expressive your characters are - there's something a bit Franco-Belgium about them. However, your line work is getting covered up by how intensive your shadows are and not in a way that isn't doing you any favors. Consider something like Sin City and how they'd do a scene at night. A lot of blacks of course, but they try to keep visibility so you understand what you're seeing. There's nothing wrong with having your shadows be lighter for your viewers to read and understand. This was a great comic still! I hope Macchiato and him make it out okay! Good work!
I like the twist that not only was Rebecca in the time loop, but perhaps everyone else is and she's the only one aware of it. You packed a lot of story into this comic, I wonder where you can go considering you immediately have the loop be shut in the first comic, but I figure you have something up your sleeve for the next rounds, having the loop finally be over and this being the final chance to save the City establishes some dire stakes. The characters are rendered well here however there is a lack of a 2-shot showing Warren's reactions on page 9 that make the conversation a bit awkward, I would employ that in the future to make the conversation flow better.
This comic is really strong to me, the pace is frenetic and stressed, the paneling and framing is very cinematic and nails the action, this comic definitely sells the destruction 100%. I really love the time-travelling effect on page 9, that's such a good way to illustrate the effect simply by just changing the lighting. I'm really impressed and hope you can continue Warren's story. Speaking of lighting, having discrete rendered lighting for almost every panel is a real feat, I think having a little more black shadow on the characters would make them stand out though, like for instance Warren on panel 2 of page 6, not having the inside of his hoodie baked in shadow makes him look a little flatter than he could considering the wonderful rim light on his face.

Mokuzuu
>> Pizza
I think I said it in my last review to your Bird War comics, but I really do love how well you depict the opponent’s character in your comics! Balancing how much spotlight you give other characters can be difficult, but you managed to give such a cool intro for Warren without shadowing Rebecca’s story and the cool story gimmick she has.
Despite the round being on the more dialogue heavy side, I really enjoyed reading it with all the different angles! It was a fun read for sure (I say as I ignore the depressing ending OH GOD NO WHY MACHINE)
>> RoRa
I felt this in your intro comic too, but you do such a good job depicting Kaiju’s as the big and menacing entity they are. The first page with the panel slowly zooming out makes such an impact on communicating that the characters are just small beings in this big disaster, and makes for a great opening.
Also my official favorite dog of the series is now Macchiato. If any thing bad happens to her I will beat up Kudra myself (I saw looking away from all the people who have fallen in their hands)
Comment posted: November 15th, 2026 at 6:33 PM