Voting is closed.
First off a great opening page you have here, all in all you have real good setup and building drama in this first half until we start to get into the insanity of the latter half. And there she is, the favorite villain Didi back in the spotlight! But I must admit that this story has me now torn: On the one hand, Didi is great, she's a show-stealer of a villain and of course I'm engaged and interested in what happens next with Ash and her. But on the other hand, the second half of this comic feels like it's pushing away the premise of the whole tournament for a whole other story. With Didi and Ash safely distanced away from Kudra's rampage and from the "kaiju disaster" scenario and genre, it feels a little like I came in to watch one movie but it's turning into a different movie before my eyes, still a good movie but not the one I came for. It's possible that this is just a first steps situation and the bigger picture would bring things back to focus of kaiju disaster survival, if you manage to make it to the next round I'd definitely recommend studying the other strong entries this round and inject some of what they're dishing out to find the right balance between Ash, Kudra and Didi.
As somber as the blue of the blood, this one really surprised me with how much it hit for otherwise being just a conversation with two people in one spot the whole time. You have a great sense of flow in your art style, I'm guessing there was some time crunch issues that prevented more colors but you worked really well with what you could here. I have to keep applauding how much you were able to give us out of the conversation, not just showcasing the two characters' personalities but also deep diving into the nature of the relationship of kaiju and society, even naming conventions, this really is a story that defines "Kaiju Disaster" from front to back. And speaking of the back end, a truly powerful ending, one of the more heartbreaking ones of the entire round, hats off to nailing your ending, one of the most useful skills one can have in storytelling as that's the thing that often stays with us first.
Talk about a phenomenally written dialog exchange during the overall chaos. This was something special, PH. I think I said it before but I have VERY much enjoyed how different everyone's comics have been. Kudra is there in most of them, but some of these stories put him in the background as a set dressing. I enjoy that the whole reason these two are even talking is because of Kudra after he'd passed by. My heart strings were tugged the moment I realized that the final dialog was winding down to a sad ending for the opponent's character. No flashy death. No heroics. Just a slow, painful demise but dulled by good company and a conversation to keep their mind off the looming end before it took them.
I enjoyed this take on Reba and Ash meeting, it was so cool to see a more direct and action packed version of events. But that twist was gut wrenching. Ash found out who killed her sister, was removed from the city forcefully and then made to watch her new friend die an agonizing death. And it didn't look fast. It looked like it went on for a long time and it hurt bad. Once again, this battle was so close in comparison, I can't choose between them as they both did what they sought out to do and did it well.
In a tournament revolving around a raging kaiju it's nice to see some of the other entries avoid featuring the creature too much right off the bat in favor of character interactions. The conversation between Reba and Ash was well done though it did definitely become a little too text heavy especially on page three I feel like a lot of that part of the conversation could be trimmed. You have a good grasp of expressions and body language but I think the highlight of the art for me has definitely gotta be those messed up legs nasty shit I love it.
Out of all the entries this one has to be the most bizarre scenario. I'm kinda super here for it though! The art is great and easy to follow even with the strange plot I wasn't lost once. This Dr. Didi person is a perfectly unhinged character and while she is very fun to follow it's a shame she takes quite a bit of the spotlight away from your opponent. Ash has been a fairly intriguing person to follow though while we get a lot about her motivations I don't really see a lot of her personality shining through. This didn't take away form the twist though, I'm very much hooked by your cliffhanger.
I’ll say I wish there had been more time for you to color everything because the first page’s colors look good! Your dialogue was very good and I enjoyed watching these two have a chat before Ash’s final moments. My only other nitpick was wishing the final two pages had the girls drawn on them, but I can understand what you were going for. Sometimes dialogue heavy pages can be stagnant but it does work here. Good job!
I love a good mystery so I was eager to see if the killer would be caught but lo and behold it was another person all along. Really enjoyed the almost vintage look your comic has too, especially the first page. I liked your utilization of another character to advance the plot, though I wish we had more time with just Ash and Reba. But boy, Reba’s death was so gnarly, I felt so bad for her! Good job all in all!
I think I will reiterate that "Radiation" feels like a pretty challenging disaster scenario to have been dealt, but I think you've found a way to incorporate it well into the story that this comic is telling. I think you've done well to seed a lot of mystery into Ash and Didi's tale that make me want to continue reading to find out what really is going on between them. Keep up the good work.
A lot of work has obviously gone into the character writing and it definitely pays off. Having these quiet moments during a kaiju attack really help to make your story stand out amongst the other more dramatic comics so I think it was wise to have a story more focused on the effect being had on the people. "Radiation" defintely seems like a challenging disaster scenario but I think you did the best you could with such a prompt.
Everyone took different reactionary takes on how characters dealt with a giant monster being a thing within the city, but I think out of all the comics yours stands alone as the most human. I can see complaints that there wasn't enough action and perhaps too much talking but what was talked ABOUT had me poring over each page. I really enjoyed your script and dialogue between these two. You did such a great job of showcasing Ash as the hardboiled candid gumshoe I was hoping for. There's just something so cool about rippin cigs and claiming "Whaddya gonna do?" while your legs are a mutated ruin and you're on a ticking clock. What better company while you're mutating than Reba and her funky arm?
Take that finite moment to just be a human and have Reba get to know Ash and her whole deal was just so fascinating. Even the mention of Reba's uncle and realization that this disaster is affecting not just her God knows who else on what scale is the heaviness I think is warranted for situations like these.
I'll always be a proponent of a good marriage of images IN comics to go with your dialogue, but that doesnt always mean more panels, or packing in the action. Sometimes attaining the impact of Ash slipping away can be summed up in a single used ciggie stub. This is I think the msot character development we've seen amongst the contestants round 1. I feel I know Reba (and Ash1) in a significant way that I hope to see more of.
From the first page I am loving where this starts. Using Ash's cigarette smoke as your comic panels is SUCH a creative choice. I love when artists get a lil abstract on how to depict the flow of storytelling and where to lead the reader. I only wish it was used throughout, or even bucked against an opposing format, like say A Didi-centric set of nuts and bolts by way of framing.
That said, what's WITHIN these panels was such a balancing act of your own lore alongside the kaiju disaster at hand that I think you managed really well. The whiplash of mundane university professor mystery to Didi cyber sci fi laboratory just worked for me. I had no idea how you were going to handle the logistics of a giant kaiju lobbing a loogie towards teeny humanoids in a method that made sense, but just saying eff it and going totally wacky with Didi teleportation was excellent. I have no rhyme or reason but just generally enjoying sharing Ash's bewilderment at coming to in a harebrained alien bottle blonde lab.I also want to doff my hat to you for dressing this Didi up in Legally Blonde cosplay XD
I love the money shot of poor Reba not only giving us the origin story of how she got her arm, but also a whole slew of other horrid mutations. This may be also odd to say, but I dug that Kudra was rather ancillary to your tale? They are such a big force that even the smallest aspects of them have a big impact that I wonder if your story would've been stronger now showing Kudra at all. Just having their scale not fit the panels, and showcasing their saliva as the titular star atraction
What a really neat comic!
A very pensive start to your kudra round! A bittersweet and somber ending for your opponent. I liked your use of spot blacks and I thought the use of blue was really nice. I also just love how stylish your rendition of Kudra was! That last page was also really beautifully done!
I do wish Ash did a little more in your comic, but I think you wrote her dialogue really well.
I look forward to seeing more comics from you!
AHH! Reading a comic from you is always a real treat!
I just love the layout of that first page! Using the Smoke from the cigarette to direct the eye around the page was really well done.
The world building you've set up, how you've tied your previous comics into this kudra plot is really interesting and I thought well executed.
My only critique I have is fairly minor, maybe pushing the values a bit more and a bit more consistent through out the comic.
Otherwise stellar job! Always wanting to see more from you dude!!!
A very bittersweet tale here, you took to heart that a death tournament does not have to be a kill or be killed situation, it can be tragic, which slots in well with your focus on the human cost of a disaster. Your dialogue writing is quite good, snappy and verbose, you have a knack for communicating a characters personality through language. As for a path forward for Reba in this tournament, I think a more clear hook in this intro would have served you, and for the future although your dialogue is strong, focusing more on tangible visual storytelling may aid you. That being said, that final page was really beautiful and wove dialogue and visual storytelling together fantastically, so clearly you're on the right path.
Wow, talk about hitting the ground running. There's setting up an arc for a tournament in round 1, and then there's kicking the doors open with a character introduction, a villain introduction, opponent and defender backstory, a resolution, a lore drop- this is like three rounds wrapped up into 11 pages lmao, it rules, and I am itching to see more of this story if you can pass this round. And wow do I love that layout on page 1, that's how you do a creative layout that still is eminently readable and clear. Woo!!
Fantastic writing. I really loved the way you told this story and I think that dialogue at the end was terrific. However, there could have been a more visual aspects to it. While this works for efficiency's sake with the limited time period, I think even some simple shot reverse shots or scenery would have worked very well for this as it left me feeling a bit deprived on that aspect. However, I love what you did and I can not wait to see you do more on this site. Please make a regular character and get participating more! Great work!
Ash is such a good character! So different from your usual and someone who I really am enjoying to see explored. Didi was a pleasant twist - but I hope we don't lose out on Ash as a result! Absolutely gnarly death for poor Reba. Those tones you're working on look so gorgeous and I am such a fan of that look. It's good to see you back in action - can't wait to see what you have next! Great work!

Mokuzuu
> Pocket
I really loved the use of color in this round A LOT! I thought using it to for the fonts was a unique and fun way to use it. The first page and the ‘blue’ is my favorite in terms of this.
I think the round was on the dialogue heavy side (if I can say that) but the dialogue was really nice, and the art and usage of colors, etc did really add good atmosphere to the conversation. Heart felt moments like this is what I like seeing in the Kaiju attack stories, so this really was a treat for myself!! (I say and still the ending breaks my heart)
Really good round writing and art wise, had a lot of fun reading through!
> Didi
I love the atmosphere this whole round carries! With all the smoke at the beginning and limited usage of color plus grayish tone, it did feel like those hardboiled comics which I thought matches Ash’s character and story arc really well. The use of colors really helped with finding and identifying characters, which I appreciate a lot!
Loved how you incorporated Reba into Ash’s story too. It’s always fun to see opponent characters have meaning in the main characters story, rather than just being a random person they find midway. The main story was equally as entertaining though! I was really wondering what angle Ash’s story would go in, and this was such a packed and entertaining first round!
Comment posted: November 15th, 2026 at 10:56 PM