Notice: This site currently does not support mobile devices.

Comic completed on November 16th 2026

Voting is closed.

Piñata

I think the biggest blow that was ironically self inflicted to you and your opponent was your page count. Deadlines and time management are a helluva thing- anyone that's entered a tournament knows as much. Its clear you two had grand ambitions, but the great thing about doing more of these tournaments is gauging your own output and what you can feasibly produce within a timeframe. I wouldn't take my words as gospel, but its been my experience you only know that through doing. Experiences like this can even help going into round two with "ok, let me try 20 pages, or 10" to see how you do.
That said, there is some great framework at work here. Your sketchwork/thumbs are legible enough to grok what was happening and your framing on certain scenes held some promising dynamicism. I especially love panel where Jon leans over Chad and idly insults them for not being Chad enough. The chemistry between these two while negotiating a kaiju disaster was taken in a very silly direction and I for one, enjoyed the banter. I want to give Chad a thesaurus so he can find other words other than 'Queen' tho lol XD

Piñata

While I can admire the ambition of doing near 50 pages for a death tournament with such a short deadline window, I feel this just set you up to disadvantage. While all art is subjective and you *should* take my critique with a grain of salt, I would argue these are more concepts for a storybook format or stream of consciousness thoughts than a comic. There are pages where the sketch is so simplified I find myself at a loss as to what I'm looking at and who the characters are outside your character and your opponent. I'm also not certain how these other characters relate or are relevant to the tournament at hand?
That said, I think what little I could see as concept of your story seemed like a promising start. I honestly think your efforts and story would've benefitted greatly from editing. For example your multiple pages explaining in writing Kudra arriving, destroying a bridge and people panicking could've been done with one splash page, where all those elements were included and the art told us what was happening as opposed to writing it beat for beat. In all honesty, re-reading this, if this wasn't a comic tournament, I think this would've shined as a fanfic as your writing was primarily doing the heavy lifting.
I can understand wanting to explain and pack in as much backstory as you can as remaining in a tournament isn't guaranteed, but I would encourage you to condense your concepts as I think your strongest point was the tail end of your pages where we see the interaction of Jon, Chad and how Kudra affects them. Despite all this, I enjoyed the moments where these two opened with dialogue and interacted 1 to 1 seeing how they viewed each other

InkySlime

This was a very ambitious attempt for the first round!
I think you had an interesting story premise and I think your pose is really nice.
I do think you may have tried to fit a lot in a very short amount of time, which admirable, but I think slimming down some of the exposition would have benefited you in the long run. as we didn't get as much focus on Kudra and your opponent. I think the first half of the comic would have made an excellent introduction comic, then jumping into the story with your opponents for this round.

You have a lot of ambition for your artistic pursuits, which is AWESOME, I think just narrowing your focus when you are on a time limit, maybe give yourself a page limit of 10 pages would benefit you greatly.
I hope you continue to do more work as I would like to see how you develop as an artist!

InkySlime

Moku you also attempted a very ambitious comic premise this round!
I really liked how you planned out your panel layouts for this round, everything read very smoothly in that regard!

you also have such a fun and cheeky sense of humor in your writing that I really enjoy.

I am going to echo what I saw you mention in the discord in regards to maybe giving yourself some page limits. Strip the story down to it's essentials. Which often is easier said than done. (I struggle with this as well, haha)
While the page count and story was admirable, I think it didn't give you enough breathing room to complete the comic as you envisioned.
I hope if you are able to find the time, I'd love to see a polished, finished version of this from you!
As always, delight seeing work from you and I can't wait to see more of your comics!

PyrasTerran

First and foremost recognizing how difficult you had it this round, give yourself some grace that you managed to submit this much at all to begin with. Comics aren't easy! In this case where the visuals don't have much to bite into I'll be focusing on what you can do to improve your narrative comics chops for future battles, be sure to take what you can from these reviews and if you see any recurring comments really think about those.

In the case of the story, I think you did yourself some disservice with the amount of focus you put on your character's backstory. Given what you've talked about perhaps it stems from a concern for your character to be understood by the audience, you want us to know as much as possible about them to inform his future actions? But this can backfire and lead to unnecessary bloating of your script; as comics are hard, just like any difficult medium, animation, film etc. you want to lean on the side of conciseness whenever possible. So for the premise of the round, where two people are caught on a bridge in a kaiju attack, we don't actually get to that incident until 22 pages in, halfway through the story. In actuality, you could have removed those first 20-22 pages and not much would be lost, because what the reader will be especially more invested in is not being told who the character is, but being SHOWN who the character is: Readers love active, dynamic characters that move and make decisions, and it's through those decisions being made that we come to learn about them. In Jon's case here, the betrayal of Chad could have been shocking, even disturbing, if you had not set up so much preamble ahead of time telling us he is twisted. This was a good opportunity for Jon to fool the audience as well as Chad, if you had started at the bridge with Jon there. Another option would be to take your origin story and drop a very compressed version of the idea right after Jon betrays Chad, because it's at that point that that part of him matters most. By frontloading all this Jon lore you've ended up deflating the impact of his later decisions.

I recommend taking a trip around now just Shadow of Kudra's rounds but also the rounds of past tournaments, look for the winners that make it through multiple rounds and see what they are doing with their characters that make them engaging. I bet you will see a common pattern of focusing on what the characters do vs what they say/are. We don't want to be told Jon is twisted, we want to *see* Jon being twisted, so in future battles I recommend you see what you can do about cutting straight to the heart of the matter! Knowing that your comic style is unorthodox, you can still give yourself limitations, if you continue to draw comics in this format I would suggest forcing yourself to do no more than 20 pages next time and see what you get out of that.

Over time you will come to learn what works and doesn't work, be bold and experiment and that includes testing limitations and boundaries for more focused storytelling!

PyrasTerran

Ultimately entertaining, life obstacles aside I think you know full well what to learn from this round and it's somewhat the same as Adloqium's: Limitations on pagecount! There is no page limit for this tournament but if you make it to the next round you should definitely consider setting one on yourself so you can carry a full-quality-consistent presentation the way you did in The Test with its 7-page limit! Maybe a happy middle around no more than 15-20 pages. I think that editing down this comic would have made it even funnier, as there's a couple gags that kind of feel like they repeat a bit, like you were trying to find time and space to fill to lengthen the comic, but I don't think it was necessary, short comics can be just as impactful as you learned in The Test as well!

Sparkle Magic Didi™

I know you had a lot going on while working on this, so I first want to say I think you did an impressive amount of work in the two days you said you had to actually work on it. Especially while recovering from a surgery.

That said, I won't focus on critiquing your art, but I will say I think it would be good for you to try to focus in on your story more. I don't want to be too harsh, because you're clearly a talented artist, but it's... kind of hard to follow. I liked the sort of fairy tale vibe the narration gave, and it's interesting to learn a bit about why Jon is the way he is, but it was just too much to pack into one comic battle. Kudra doesn't show up until halfway through your comic, your opponent isn't there until page 28. It can be hard, but making some cuts to parts of your story to help it be clearer for the audience is a vital skill to have. A bit more planning, organization, and giving yourself a page limit would save you (& your wrist!) a lot of grief. The best way to learn is by doing, and by learning from others! Study the comics you like, and see how they tell their stories. I look forward to seeing your growth as a storyteller!

Sparkle Magic Didi™

Part of what I'll say for you Moku, is the same as I said to your opponent, there's so much here! There's no way any human being could have done 32 pages in two weeks O_O I admire the ambition, and it is a competent story, but I hope you can learn to make cuts to your script where appropriate, because the big page count impacted how polished you could make this. I can't really comment too much on the unfinished bits, but the art you did have a chance to give more time to looks good! I'd rather have 5 pages that are inked like your last one, than 32 roughs. What you've written is a charming, easy to follow story though! You characterized both Jon and Chad well, their personalities were very well communicated. I like that Chad gets a jacket like Jon's in the end, and that his bunbun also made it. Also a special shout out to your lettering, it's very well done (other than a few typos), especially Jon's inner voice.

RoRaDraws

I see the vision for what you intended and I'm sad to see (and hear) that things didn't work out with your health and mental well being. I do hope you come back and finish this up, because it's wonderfully set up, I can tell you were aiming for sweeping visuals, full page panels packed with detail. If this was going to be colored, that was even more ambitious given the page number, but please do finish it when and if you have the time/desire. This looks like it would have been incredible fully lined and shaded.

RoRaDraws

Just like with your opponent, I can see the vision. There's some good silly parts here, some over the top dialog and moments and it's a shame that a lot of it is still just in sketches form. But for the amount of pages you put into this thing, I'll say it's still rather impressive with the time constraints you had placed on you. If you wrote this, THEN starting drawing it, I commend you, that's really incredible how many pages you were able to write. I hope you come back and finish this one as well!

Pizza Man

Despite the large page count the story went quicker than expected after the first few pages. While at first the page count was daunting I appreciate the spacing of the text it really did help the flow of the comic though in the future I think you could definitely shave it down a significant amount especially the first twenty pages, those would've been better suited for a side comic in my opinion. While the art is sketchy it was easy to follow for the most part and I was never lost as to what the characters were doing. While it appears to be a stylistic choice the narration of events is a bit excessive. I'm not saying it needs to be cut entirely but I would avoid narrating what is happening on the page in the future.

Pizza Man

Congrats on making it to the finish line! I think it's always better to get something in than nothing at all and 32 pages is sure something, dang you two really went balls to the walls when it came to ambition for this round one! I'm not gonna lie though this was a bit hard to finish. There were a lot of points where it was a difficult to decipher who was who and the pacing is a bit slow considering the situation the characters are in. That being said the banter was hilarious and made the characters feel fleshed out. I really like how you killed your opponent as well Chad is coping hard lol.

Ninja

I'm sure you've heard it a lot already to keep the page count down and getting some more panels up on your pages but I have another idea that would be interesting for you. From what I see and how you present everything, I think you could get away with something more Story book vibes, like some Dr Seuss stuff you know. You combine some more of your dialogue together, combine some of the action and I think it would look very nice. For example when you were introducing Jon, I think you couldve also introduced Kudra in the background. I think it could be very interesting. And I know you were talking about in the discord how you haven't interacted with alot of graphic novels and comics before but im sure you're familiar with fairy tales and picture books like that, so it could be a really nice start to moving towards more traditional comics. Great work!

Ninja

Big thing for you Moku will be giving yourself a hard page limit. Your Test stuff was very good and compact so I know you can do it, but I think you got a bit too lost in the sauce here with so many pages. When you get to your inks in it's really crisp and very nice, there was just a bit too much to go for. It's still a very good comic I just want to see something a bit more finished from you. Great job!

PocketHexapod

I'm extremely intrigued by Jon and Lentica's combined backstories, the split and refinement of one being into two to become the absolute SITUATION their existence is, two pure, well meaning wishes creating a frail little creature and the talented but terrible man she depends on. I need this explored, I need theories written about it, I need to know what the culmination of that is. It is such a GOOD mysterious hook for a character concept.

That being said, I did have to go over this one multiple times which took a while because of its sheer length, the simplicity of some of the pages and in a lot of cases the lack of panel borders. My imagination did a lot of the heavy lifting in the end and I ended up having a good time with it, but every so often a more abstract page or formatting choice with the text did break my immersion and I had to get back into the moment.

All in all, you are a MACHINE for getting out 48 pages, the bridge scenario was utilized well for drama, and for as small as his role in the present-day story was, Chad was totally in character, and him being reduced down to a useful tool by Jon only for him to try and make excuses for it later is the exact kind of morally bankrupt behavior I expected/feared to see out of this story. Also Her Royal Highness Queen Moose lives on! Great job!

PocketHexapod

Chad is so dumb I love him so much. Absolute chivalrous clown of a man, and him getting stuck with the extremely pretty Jon is a match made in hell (positive). Speaking of, I love the justice you did Jon in his portrayal. In a lot of ways it combined with Jon's backstory as outlined in your opponent's comic to put forth a full exploration of Jon's duplicity and character. Chad's ultimate decision to stand by himself and "save" Jon despite their manipulation only for it to blow up in Jon's face is also an amazingly ironic way to end Jon's arc and give Chad a way to dip out of the whole bridge hazard, which is also represented extremely well here.

I'm torn because the pacing and panel work of this whole comic is so so good, but my eyeballs yearn for that precious lined artwork, and I know that sacrificing your short time to accomplish that would have reduced the amount of pages and therefor crunched the pacing down. I both totally understand the choice to leave panels in the roughs for the sake of pacing but also am a greedy greedy insect who wants the juicy art I see in the finished panels.

What I'm trying to say is I had a really good time, both major characters were represented extremely well, the scenario was represented very well on top of that, and as a bonus Lentica surviving is extremely satisfying. Great job!

tictoc64

I was really taken by the story you managed to show in such a short time, I really love the characterization of both Jon and Chad in your comic. When you fully expressed your style I thoroughly enjoyed the style your art has and I think overall the story has a good pacing. I'd agree that in future some of these pages could be condensed down to fit a tighter page count but despite that I still enjoyed the use of pages as narrative pacing when you really went for it! Great work!

tictoc64

The characterizations in this comic were very good, I enjoyed seeing the interactions between Jon and Chad and the way Jon used Chad for his own merit. Extra props for sticking firmly on the disaster scenario and telling a decently sized story within those parameters. Honestly the sketches got hard to discern for me so I think maybe scale was holding you back from more time dedicated to individual pages. Otherwise I had a lot of fun reading!

Goldie

While the comic is very unfinished, I still appreciate your efforts to your story. I think you could have “trimmed the fat” a little to decrease the page count in the long run, meaning removing or failing back any part of the story that wasn’t necessarily needed. The beginning could have been a little shorter to give us more time with Jon and Chad, since they’re both supposed to be the focal points of the story.

Goldie

Even though the comic isn’t finished, you did a good job with what you had. I’ll say that you could have trimmed down your story just a bit to reduce the pages you ended up with, as I think you could have told this story with a smaller page count. When doing a script for comics, it can be handy to go over it more than once to try and see what can be condensed to trim away any extra padding you don’t need.

Eric

"Brevity is the soul of wit." Your passion is on full display here and you clearly had a bold vision for how this comic was supposed to go, but there is a point where you should seek the services of your fellow members to act as editor to help trim the fat. The entire beginning intro with the story regarding an angel feels so divorced from Jon, Chad, and Kudra as a whole that if you were intending to use it as your modus operandi for resolving much of the story, you could have afforded to save it for later rounds. While I am certain you're discouraged for many reasons regarding how this comic turned out, I really would like to see you to stay and grow your abilities in story-telling using the comic format. I hope to see more of you. Good work.

Eric

Good on you for the attempt. I wasn't expecting to see you trying to produce so much here, especially because this is an above and beyond ambition for this comic's first round that was unnecessary. However, the work that is finished is quite cute and the sketches you're providing are understandable enough that I have an idea what's going on. All that to say however, you are capable of stronger work. If my opinion is worth anything, I want you to limit yourself to no more than 10 pages next round. You could really benefit a lot by utilizing in media res or other storytelling techniques here, because you very clearly can accomplish that. Your previous comics are proof of that. Even so, I am eager to see what you do next round. Good work.

Doe

Your sketches are readable, have a consistent look overall and I think you have have a hang on how to write shorter stories.
My big issue is that you didn't really need a page count in the 40s. A lot of these pages are basically splash pages (one big illustration that takes up the whole canvas), and had you grabbed each of these scenes, put them into panels, and then arranged those panels into pages of 5 panels, you wouldn't have had to draw as much.

I understand that you don't quite understand comics as a medium, which is why you should study all kinds of compositions by various artists, see how they structure their story beats into panels.

Alternatively you could lean into the "picturebook" look you have going on and have multiple illustrations in one page alongside text. Just try to put "more" into each page, rather than making a page-by-page sequence.

Doe

Hi moku :)

Not sure how to comment on this. I think your art is nice in the parts where it is finished, but you did wayyyy too much here for a story that could've been told with 50% less pages. Your sketches kind of suffer from not being super readable at times (not being able to tell who is who), as well.

I know you and I come from Deviantart OCTs, so I'm gonna give you some feedback in regards to that: the tournaments here in Oculama almost always last 2 weeks per round, rather than a month; You need to adapt your page count accordingly.
At maximum you should be doing 14 pages (1 page a day), because if you go longer you'll inevitably have to crunch. Limit yourself some more and you'll be able to make great stories with less.